top of page

À La Carte or Table d’Hôte? A Brief History of How We Order Dinner. From Parisian dining rooms to 35 years of Pied à Terre

1 day ago
5 min read

Have you ever wondered why restaurants have menus?


Or why we use French expressions such as à la carte and table d’hôte without giving them a second thought? The humble restaurant menu has a rather colourful history, full of French innovation, culinary extravagance and, occasionally, a little deception. And as we celebrate 35 years of Pied-à-Terre, I thought it might be fun to explore where it all began and explain why our Anniversary Menu is actually a rather splendid example of something the French call table d’hôte.


Before the Menu, There Was the Host


Wind the clock back a few hundred years and dining out was a very different experience.

Before restaurants as we know them became established, travellers and townsfolk might eat at inns, taverns or communal dining establishments. You generally ate what was being cooked that day, often at a shared table, at a set time and for a fixed price. There was rarely choice. No agonising over whether to have the fish or the beef. No asking whether the sauce could come on the side. You ate what you were given. This was the world of the table d’hôte, literally translated as the host's table. The expression describes a meal offered at a fixed price, traditionally with a predetermined selection of dishes. In its earliest forms, it was as much about communal hospitality as it was about eating. Rather wonderfully, it has survived for centuries.


The French Revolution Changed Dinner Forever


The modern restaurant began to emerge in Paris during the 18th century. One popular story credits a Parisian soup seller named Boulanger, who supposedly opened an establishment around 1765 serving restorative broths. The story has been embellished over the years, and historians debate the details, but it captures an important change in French dining culture.Instead of simply taking your place at a communal table, you could often sit at your own table, choose what you wanted and pay for individual dishes. Then came the French Revolution in 1789. The upheaval of aristocratic households helped reshape the culinary profession. Chefs who had previously cooked for wealthy families found opportunities in the expanding restaurant trade. Parisian dining became increasingly sophisticated, and the restaurant menu developed alongside it. The diner was becoming king or queen. Rather ironic, given what had just happened to the monarchy.


À La Carte: The Freedom to Choose


The expression à la carte translates roughly as "according to the card", the card being the menu.

Instead of paying a fixed price for a prescribed meal, diners could select individual dishes, each with its own price. A starter here, a main course there, perhaps a pudding if one's waistband permitted. It sounds perfectly normal today, but the idea of choosing your own dinner from a list of individually priced dishes represented a significant change in restaurant culture. By the 19th century, the grand restaurants of Paris had developed elaborate menus offering extraordinary choice. Some ran to dozens, even hundreds, of dishes. Imagine the kitchen organisation required, not to mention the food waste. The legendary Auguste Escoffier, one of the great architects of modern French cuisine, helped bring order to the professional kitchen through his brigade system and championed a more disciplined approach to cooking and service. The à la carte menu became a hallmark of restaurant dining, offering individuality, flexibility and, perhaps most importantly, choice. It remains a wonderful way to eat. At Pied à Terre, I have always believed there is something rather civilised about choosing  exactly what you fancy rather than being told what you are going to have.


Table d’Hôte: The Original Set Menu


While à la carte was flourishing, table d’hôte never disappeared. Instead, it evolved.

Today, the term generally describes a menu offered at a fixed price, with a predetermined number of courses and sometimes a limited or no choice within each course. It is the ancestor of the modern set lunch, prix fixe menu and, in some respects, the contemporary tasting menu. For the kitchen, a carefully constructed set menu allows chefs to plan ingredients, control waste, work with the seasons and deliver exceptional consistency. For the guest, it offers clarity, value and the reassurance that the chef has thought carefully about how the meal comes together.

A table d’hôte menu is not necessarily a cheaper or lesser experience. Far from it.

Some of the world's greatest restaurants have built their reputations around menus in which the chef, rather than the customer, makes most of the decisions. The difference is that you are buying into the chef's vision.


The Tasting Menu: A Modern Cousin or is it….?


Then, of course, there is the tasting menu.  Thought of as relatively modern menu format now, actually it is not, dinner in First Class on The Titanic was a mere 10 course tasting experience:



The separate À La Carte Restaurant was an exclusive dining room where wealthy passengers could order individually. There is a wonderful story here for Pied à Terre: in 1912, a luxury liner offered both a grand structured dinner and the freedom of à la carte dining. More than a century later, the same distinction remains relevant to fine restaurants. Although elaborate sequences of dishes have existed for centuries, the modern restaurant tasting menu became particularly fashionable in the latter part of the 20th century. Rather than ordering a traditional starter, main course and dessert, diners are invited on a culinary journey through a succession of smaller dishes. It gives chefs the opportunity to tell a story, showcase techniques and introduce ingredients that might otherwise be overlooked. At Pied à Terre, tasting menus have long been part of our identity, including our commitment to imaginative plant-based cooking. But I have never believed that one style of menu should entirely replace another. Some evenings you want to surrender yourself to the kitchen. Other evenings you simply want to choose your dinner. Both are perfectly respectable ambitions.

.

Our 35th Anniversary Menu: A Little History on a Plate


Which brings me neatly to Pied à Terre. We opened our doors on Charlotte Street in December 1991. Thirty-five years later, we're still here, still cooking, still welcoming guests and still rather passionate about the business of restaurants. To celebrate our 35th anniversary, we introduced our £49.50 Anniversary Menu. Strictly speaking, it is a table d’hôte menu - a carefully composed menu, offered at a fixed price, designed to deliver a complete dining experience without the financial uncertainty that can sometimes accompany a meal in a Michelin-starred restaurant. Simply, it is a concept with centuries of history behind it. I rather like the idea that something which feels fresh and contemporary is actually rooted in one of the oldest traditions of European restaurant dining. Of course, our chefs have rather more sophisticated equipment than their 18th-century predecessors, and nobody is expected to share a communal table with a stranger, unless, of course, they particularly want to. But the principle remains unchanged: good food, thoughtfully prepared, generously served and offered at a price that makes sense.


So, Which Is Better?


À la carte or table d’hôte? The answer, of course, is neither. Or both. À la carte celebrates freedom and individuality. Table d’hôte celebrates the chef's judgement, the rhythm of a meal and the pleasures of a carefully considered menu, but with little or often no choice. But both have earned their place at the restaurant table.


After 35 years in this wonderful, occasionally infuriating, always fascinating industry, I have learnt that guests don't all want the same thing. And why should they? Some come for an extravagant tasting menu with carefully paired wines. Others want a delicious lunch, a glass of something lovely and to be back at their desks before anyone notices. The beauty of a good restaurant is being able to accommodate both.


So, next time you find yourself studying a menu, spare a thought for the centuries of culinary history behind that little piece of paper. And if you join us for our Anniversary Menu, you can tell your dining companion that you're enjoying a table d’hôte. It sounds rather grander than a set menu, doesn't it?


Bon appétit!







David Moore, Founder and Owner of Pied à Terre.

Contact Us

34 Charlotte St,

London, W1T 2NH

Opening Hours

Monday: Closed

Tuesday: 5:30 - 9:00pm

Wednesday – Friday: 12 - 2pm, 5:30 - 9:00pm

Saturday: 12 - 2:30pm, 5:30 - 9:00pm

Sunday: Closed

​​​

Follow Us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
michelin 2026 1 .jpg
TripAdvisor Logo

Sign up to the Pied à Terre newsletter

Food and restaurant interior video and photography by Jodie Hinds, Claude Okamoto and KE Designs.

NEWBRIAR COMPANY LIMITED, registered as a limited company in England and Wales under company number: 02591950.

Registered Company Address: 34 Charlotte Street, London, England, W1T 2NH.

Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookie Policy | Trading Terms

© 2025. The content on this website is owned by us and our licensors. Do not copy any content (including images) without our consent.

bottom of page